Learning Theories and Integration Models
Home
Directed
Constructivist
T-Integration

Q1: Fruit and fish, which one is good to our health?
A1: Both!

Q2: Directed Instruction and Constructivist Instruction, which approach is useful for learning?
A2: Not either-or, but both!

Over the next decade, educators will confront the task of identifying the best mix of approaches for each content area.

Differences between directed and constructivist instructional methods:

Instructional method
Directed method
Constructivist method
Metaphor
Acquisition
Participation
Philosophy foundation Knowledge has a separate, real existence of its own outside the human mind: learning happens when this knowledge is transmitted to and acquired by learners. Human construct all knowledge in their minds by participating in certain experience; learning happens when one constructs both mechanisms for learning and his or her own unique version of the knowledge, colored by background, experience, and aptitude.
Theoretical Foundation Skinner (Behaviorism)
Information-processing (a branch of cognitive psychology)
Gagne (Provide tools for teacher based on behaviorism and cognitive.)
Other branches of cognitive psychology:
Dewey (Grandfather of constructivism)
Vygotsky (Building a scaffold to learning)
Piaget (Cognitive development in children)
Bruner (Learning as discovery)
Teacher roles Transmitter of knowledge; Expert source; director of skills and concept development through structured experience Guide and facilitator as students generate their own knowledge; collaborative resource and assistant as students explore topics
Student roles Receive information; demonstrate competence; all students learn same materials Collaborate with others; develop competence; students may learn different material
Curriculum characteristics Based on skill and knowledge hierarchies; skills taught one after the other in set sequence Based on projects that foster both higher-level and lower level skills concurrently
Learning goals Stated in terms of mastery learning and behavioral competence in a scope and sequence Stated in terms of growth from where student began and increased ability to work independently and with others
Types of activities Lecture, demonstration, discussions, student practice, seatwork, testing Group projects, hands-on exploration, product development
Assessment strategies Written tests and development of products matched to objectives; all tests and products match set criteria; same measures for all students Performance tests and products such as portfolios; quality measured by rubrics and checklists; measures may differ among students